THE WAR AT SEA

THExNAVAL BATTLES OF CORONEL AND THE FALKLAND ISLANDS

NOVEMBER – DECEMBER  1914

Acknowledgements

Map-Tsingtao: Jaoats.blogspot.com Battle of Coronel: Britpolitics.co.uk by English artist William Lionel Wyllie Map-Cape Horn: Britpolitics.co.uk Battle of Falkland Islands: en.wikipedia.org by English artist William Lionel Wyllie Poster: en.wikipedia.org by English artist Edith Kemp-Welch, Scarborough Museum Trust. Admiral von Spee: geni.com. artist unknown. U-boat: gog.com

     As we have seen, the first major naval encounter of the war was the First Battle of Heligoland Bight, fought in August. This was a clear victory for the British Navy – as was to be expected – though, behind the scenes of jubilation (in the corridors of power), there was some real concern about defective staff work, the lack of a clear command structure, and some of the tactics employed. The second major encounter, however, the Battle of Coronel, was quite a different matter. Fought in the distant waters of the South Pacific, close to the coast of Chile, it was, for the British, a complete, unmitigated disaster, ending in the loss of two armoured cruisers and the lives of 1,600 men, including Rear Admiral Sir Christopher Cradock, commander of the British squadron. In contrast, seven German seamen were wounded. It was the first time in over a century that the British navy had been defeated, and so decisively.


     When the war broke out, it was a comparatively easy task for the British to blockade the German High Seas Fleet, the biggest threat to Britain’s home waters. Constant surveillance of the German ports along a small stretch of coast line near Heligoland Bight, together with total command of the Straits of Dover, meant that German warships could be kept locked in, and merchant shipping – munitions and food supplies – could be kept locked out of the North Sea. But it was a different story in the Far East, where the Germans had quite a large presence of warships, aimed at attacking merchant shipping and the vessels being used to bring Allied troops to the Western Front. Prime among this force was the East Asiatic Squadron, commanded by Vice-Admiral Maximilian von Spee, and including the two heavy cruisers the SMS Sharnhorst and the SMS Gnisenau. This was based at Tsingtao (see map), Germany’s naval base for Asia and the Pacific on the Shantung Peninsula in northern China. (Taken over by Britian’s ally, Japan, as we have seen, in November of this year.)


THE BATTLE OF CORONEL, NOVEMBER 1914


     The Allies needed to keep an eye on this particular squadron, but this proved easier said than done. It was known that it left Tsingtao at the end of June, and it was assumed that it was making for Java, from where it could attack Allied merchant and naval shipping in the Indian Ocean. It was not in fact until early October that it was reported that the Spee squadron had bombarded Tahiti and, in fact, was clearly heading for American waters to attack shipping on the trade routes along the west coast of South America. Rear-AdmiralxSir Christopher Cradock, commander of the 4th Cruiser Squadron, was assigned the task of engaging the enemy, but his force was insufficient to mount an attack. His two heavy cruisers, HMS Good Hope and HMS Monmouth, were seriously undergunned, and the additional support given by the Admiralty, the battleship HMS Canopus, whilst it had four 12” guns, was virtually worn out and, with a speed of only 16.5 knots, never made it to the battle! Furthermore, the promise to send HMS Defence, a modern-armoured cruiser, never materialised. It was diverted to the coming Gallipoli Campaign.

WW1-1914-1918-WW1-1914-1918-WW1-1914-1918-WW1-1914-1918-WW1-1914-1918-WW1

     In such circumstances, Cradock faced a dilemma. Should he take on an enemy he could not possibly defeat and lose ships as a consequence, or should he avoid an encounter altogether? Fully aware that his friend, Rear Admiral Ernest Trowbridge, was at this very time awaiting a court martial for “failing to engage the enemy”, he felt duty bound to fight to the end. Ironically, in the meantime, Baron Fisher, the First Sea Lord, had sent him a message stating that he was not expected to fight if he did not have the support of HMS Canopus. He never received that message! As a consequence, the battle took place on the 1st November, off the Chilean port of Coronel, and was over in a matter of hours. Both the flagship HMS Good Hope and the Monmouth were badly damaged and then destroyed, with the loss of all hands.


THE BATTLE OF THE FALKLAND ISLANDS, DECEMBER 1914


    This was an outstanding victory for the German Imperial Navy, but, as Vice Admiral von Spee was well aware, a formidabl force would be swiftly on its way to seek revenge. After a 24 hour stay at Valparaiso – the time permitted in a neutral port – he took his squadron around Cape Horn to Mas-a-Fuera, a small island off the east coast of Chile. It was from here that, on the 8th December, he launched an attack upon the Falkland Islands, aiming to destroy the coaling facilities and the radio station at Port Stanley. But a British squadron, led by Admiral Sir Doveton Sturdee, and containing two of the British navy’s most powerful battle cruisers – HMS Invincible and HMS Inflexible – had already arrived at the Falklands. Spee’s squadron was immediately bombarded by the 12-inch guns of the Canopus, beached at Port Stanley to provide a secure firing platform, and he had no alternative but to make a rapid escape. It was a valient effort, but after several hours the British ships caught up with him, and he could no longer avoid combat. Both the SMS Scharnhorst and the SMS Gneisenau were sunk, together with the light cruisers SMS Leipzig and SMS Nürenberg. The light cruiser SMS Dresden, did manage to escape, but it was caught and destroyed three months later off the coast of Chile. The loss of German lives was put at 1,900, and 215 seamen were captured.


     Incidentally, when Admiral von Spee stopped off at Valparaiso following his victory at Coronel, he was congratulated on his success and presented with a bouquet of flowers. The flowers, he quipped, would do nicely for his grave. He had no illusions as to the British response! As the First Lord of the Admiralty, Winston Churchill, later wrote: “He was a cut-flower in a vase, fair to see yet bound to die.” ……


     …… Ironicallyxenough, a week after the Battle of the Falkland Islands, way down in the South Atlantic, a German task force, including four battle cruisers, evaded the British Grand Fleet in home waters – the North Sea! – and bombarded the English seaside towns of Scarborough, Hartlepool and Whitby. In the attack, over 130 civilians were killed and nearly 600 were wounded. The attack resulted in a public outcry against the incompetence of the Royal Navy, and became a rallying cry for a huge recruitment campaign. And, as we shall see, it also led to The Battle of Dogger Bank in February 1915.




     AdmiralxMaximilian von Spee (1861-1914) entered the German navy in 1878. Over 1887 and 1888, he commanded the port of Duala in the German colony of Kamerun, and in 1899 took part in the Boxer Rebellion. He was made chief of staff of the North Sea Fleet in 1908 and then, at the end of 1912, was selected to command the East Asia Squadron, a prestigious appointment which gave him a wide field of operation. At the outbreak of war his squadron included two armoured cruisers, SMS Scharnhorst (his flagship) and SMS Gneisenau, and two light cruisers, SMS Emden and SMS Nürenberg. He had plans to operate in the China Sea, but following Japan’s declaration of war against Germany, he assessed the likely dangers (including the strength of the Royal Australian Navy), and decided it was best to search out Allied commercial shipping along the west coast of South America. He crossed the Pacific, attacking the French colony of Tahiti en route, and it was off the coast of Chile that he won his outstanding victory at the Battle of Coronel. It was a victory for which he was going to pay dearly. Having moved his squadron into the South Atlantic to launch an attack upon the Falkland Islands, he was met by a substantially reinforced British fleet. Overtaken and seriously outgunned, the Sharnhorst went down with all hands. (And the Spee family also lost their two sons who had been serving in other vessels!). ….. Twenty-five years later, almost to the day, following the Battle of the River Plate (in the Second World War) the new pocket battleship named SMS Admiral Graf Spee was scuttled by its crew off the coast of Uruguay, in those distant waters of the South Atlantic.


     This British victory did much to restore the navy’s prestige and to keep open vital trade routes in the South Atlantic and South Pacific. And it gave a morale boost to the Entente at a time when the war was not going too well on the Western Front. The Battle of Coronel had been avenged, but, needless to say, it was never to be forgotten by the Admiralty.


     And the Battle of the Falkland Islands marked, too, the end of the threat posed by the German cruiser against Allied shipping. From now on it was to be the u-boat that was to dominate Germany’s war at sea and bring the Allies to their knees. It was a policy which grew in strength and, by April 1917, was coming close to fruition. As we shall see, it was after the Battle of Dogger Bank that Germany, in response to the British blockade, declared the waters around the British Isles a “war zone” and introduced its own blockade against the Allies.

To go back to the Dateline, click HERE

CLICK HERE

BFI